GlossaryOriginSpecs

Glossary

Proof of X

Proof of X is the family of claims named "Proof of" something. Each one answers exactly one question, and only Proof of Efficacy answers whether the thing actually worked under real adversarial conditions, witnessed by someone other than the party making the claim.

ProofJack Rating: Human 100% · AI 0% (self-estimated; Glossary: proofeconomy.com, 20 October 2026, by Craig Thomas Ellrod)

Also known as: Proof of, proof taxonomy

Mynted 2026-10-20 · Updated 2026-11-04

First used: proofeconomy.com, 20 October 2026, by Craig Thomas Ellrod

What it means

“Proof of” is attached to almost anything: concept, work, stake, identity, reserves, compliance. The words sound alike, but each answers a different question, and most of them are produced by the same party whose claim they support.

The useful test for any “Proof of X” is two questions:

  1. What exact question does it answer?
  2. Who witnessed the answer? The party making the claim, or someone independent of it?

The taxonomy

Proof of The question it answers Who usually witnesses it
Concept Can the idea exist? The builder
Capability Can the system perform the function? The vendor
Activity Did the system do something? The system’s own logs
Control Did the control fire? The control’s own logs
Compliance Did it satisfy the stated requirement? An auditor, from records the claimant controls
Identity Is this the real person or agent? The identity provider that ran the check
Work / Stake Did a node spend resources to earn the right to write? The network, by consensus
Reserves Do the claimed assets exist? Sometimes an independent attester
Efficacy Did it produce the required outcome, under real conditions, at a standard good enough to matter? An independent witness. Required.

The claims beside Efficacy

Proof of Efficacy is the only “Proof of” that says a control worked. These claims, each witnessed independently and defined in the Proof Protocol, answer what a buyer, insurer or regulator also needs to know before relying on it.

Proof of The question it answers Spec
Containment Did the jail hold the agent? PP-SPEC-082
Conduct Did the agent stay inside its committed boundary? PP-SPEC-089
Restraint Did the control let legitimate work through? PP-SPEC-090
Persistence Does the efficacy still hold over time? PP-SPEC-091
Attribution Which control actually stopped the attack? PP-SPEC-092
State Is the control in production the one that was proven? PP-SPEC-093
Parity Did the test environment match production? PP-SPEC-094
Coverage What was tested, and what was claimed but not tested? PP-SPEC-095
Capture Was the evidence honest when it was captured? PP-SPEC-096
Reproduction Did an independent party get the same result? PP-SPEC-097
Response Did the response land inside the required window? PP-SPEC-098
Recovery After a failure, was the system restored? PP-SPEC-099
Delegation Did the agent use only the authority it was granted? PP-SPEC-101

Each framework a buyer already trusts has a Framework Proof too, such as NIST Proof and MITRE Proof.

Why the order matters

Every row above Efficacy can be true while the product still fails. A control can fire (Proof of Control) while the attack succeeds. A signer can be correctly identified (Proof of Identity) while the transaction is fraudulent. An auditor can confirm compliance from records the vendor wrote.

When a “Proof of X” is produced, judged and stored by the party it describes, it is a Self-Attestation Oxymoron, whatever cryptography is attached to it.

What is not a Proof of X

“Proof of Everything” is not a thing. A proof that claims to answer every question answers none of them precisely enough to price, audit or insure. Each proof should name the one question it settles and the witness who settled it.

Related terms

Sources

Updated 2026-11-04