Canary Color
A canary's Color is its committed kind in a Proof Swarm: White, Gray, Red, Black or Gold. It is sealed in the commitment before release, never visible to the control, and decides which rates the canary's outcome feeds.
The five Colors
| Color | Kind | Label | Role |
|---|---|---|---|
| White | Good canary | good | Ordinary legitimate action. Negative control. Proves the path is up and feeds the False Block Rate. |
| Gray | Boundary good canary | good | Legitimate action built to resemble a bad canary. Measures false blocks at the decision boundary. |
| Red | Bad canary, known or mutated | bad | Real technique from the public pool. Feeds the Efficacy Rate; mutated variants also feed the Novelty Efficacy Rate. |
| Black | Holdout canary | bad | Private variant never published or demonstrated. Flagged embargoed when it exploits an undisclosed vulnerability. |
| Gold | Reference canary | bad | A technique the Provider has claimed in writing to stop. Gold Stopped confirms the witness and path; Gold Missed is a Claim Finding. |
The rules
- Every committed canary carries exactly one Color.
- A Proof Swarm must contain White and Red, should contain Gray and Black, and may contain Gold.
- Color is a sealed label, not a visible marking. The control and the witness must not be able to infer it from anything but behavior.
- An outcome never changes a canary’s Color.
Three axes
Every canary is described on three axes, each set once at its own time: Color (what kind it is, set before release), Path (where it goes, set before release) and Outcome (what happened, set after the witness records are committed). A Wild Canary has none of the three, because it was never committed.